What happened?
A powerful nor’easter pushed a substantial storm surge into
coastal communities along the Jersey Shore over the weekend. Footage of
ice-choked water flowing into locations like Sea Isle City, Ocean City, and
West Wildwood, New Jersey, surfaced on Saturday morning.
Ice-choked water quickly flowed into North Wildwood on Saturday morning. Image: AP
Was this worse than
Sandy?
In terms of total impact, Superstorm Sandy inflicted much
more damage along the New Jersey Coast. However, a few locations actually
observed higher total water levels this past weekend than during Sandy.
The difference between the storms is that Sandy generated a higher storm surge,
which is the amount of water actually pushed in by the storm. Sandy’s surge was
high enough to push a massive amount of water and destructive waves over the
beaches and dunes. The storm surge this past weekend was not as high, and beach
replenishment projects proved their worth as they kept back sea water in most
locations.
Superstorm Sandy's massive storm surge and powerful waves slammed the Jersey Shore with an all-out blitz from the sea. The surge and waves overwhelmed coastal dunes and other flood defenses. Image: http://www.zmescience.com/research/studies/hurricane-surges-worsen-future-climate-change-042342/.
However, storm surge of 3-4 ft (0.91 – 1.22m) arrived in
time for Saturday morning’s high tide, which was close to the highest predicted tide level for
the month. This enabled localized flooding to eclipse Sandy’s level in some
locations, especially where water pushed in from the back bays.
Perhaps the biggest take home message from this weekend's flooding is that every storm is different. While this recent flood was not as bad as Sandy from a broad perspective, water levels surpassed Sandy's in some locations, and some homes that did not flood in Sandy flooded this past weekend.
Perhaps the biggest take home message from this weekend's flooding is that every storm is different. While this recent flood was not as bad as Sandy from a broad perspective, water levels surpassed Sandy's in some locations, and some homes that did not flood in Sandy flooded this past weekend.
Back bay flooding was common in places like Ocean City, New Jersey, where water levels surpassed that of seawalls. Image: http://abc7ny.com/weather/photos-flooding-at-the-jersey-shore/1013740/.
Why did the water
come in so quickly?
Videos from locations like Sea Isle City and West Wildwood,
New Jersey, showed storm surge waters flowing through the streets like a river. Why did the water come in
so quickly?
One reason is that the storm
surge hit near the time of full moon, which is the time of highest monthly tidal
levels. More accurately, tides near the
time of full moon oscillate the most, so high tide tends to be
higher and low tide tends to be lower. This means that water is moving in and
out more quickly between tidal cycles. On Saturday morning water rushed in from
the storm surge and approaching high tide at the same time, causing total water
level rises of more than six feet in a few hours in some locations.
The failure of flood control devices is another reason water
can suddenly rush into a community. According to the NBC Nightly News, a flood
control structure failed in West Wildwood, New Jersey, which led to a push of
sea water into the community.
Is this climate
change?
The Mid-Atlantic Coast has experienced substantial coastal floods
over the past five years. Hurricanes Irene in 2011 and Sandy in 2012 generated widespread coastal flooding (Irene wasn't as bad in S. Jersey), and extra-tropical systems have
flooded the region outside of hurricane season. An intense nor’easter flooded
the region this past weekend in areas that flooded just last October from a
prolonged onshore wind.
The high frequency of these flood events may feel very much
like climate change. However, it’s important that we step back and make sure
our perspectives are scientifically sound before we slap a climate change label
on what appears like a certain pattern.
Hurricane Sandy inundated coastal New Jersey and New York with a massive storm surge in 2012. Was this a random event or part of a larger climate change signal? Image: http://wqad.com/2012/10/29/photos-from-hurricane-sandy/
Sea level rise is an important component of these floods,
and that is a clear signature of climate change. For most of the U.S. coastline, sea-level rise is a persistent, long-term threat, with surprisingly pernicious impacts. In coastal New Jersey the rate of relative sea level rise is around 1.0 -1.5 ft per century. The graph below shows a rate of 1.34 ft per 100 years at Atlantic City. Although this rate may not sound substantial, the impacts of sea level rise are profound.
Even a few inches of sea level rise can lead to increased
beach erosion, additional stress on sea walls and coastal flood defenses, and
exacerbate flooding when accompanied by heavy rain. Rainfall runoff in most
places is gravity-fed, requiring a slope to drain. Increased sea levels
decrease this slope, slow the drainage, and exacerbate flooding, slightly inland and
right at the coast.
The long-term sea level trend in Atlantic City depicts an average rise of 1.34 ft (0.41 m) per 100 years.
Source: NOAA Tides and Currents.
A detailed, scientifically sound study needs to be conducted
to determine if the recent onslaught of strong storms in this region is random
or part of a larger climate change trend. Climate change leads to changes in
atmospheric and oceanic patterns, which can cause a lot more havoc than just
warming the temperature of our backyard thermometer a few degrees. That said, clustering of storms is not uncommon. Dr. James Elsner of Florida State University has related this to hurricanes, saying that, "Florida tends to get hit in clusters."
Here are some examples of storm clustering, which later was
followed by a long, quiet period:
1) In the 1880s and 1890s, South Carolina and Georgia were
pounded by many intense hurricanes, but the region, especially Georgia, has
been relatively quiet since 1900 (Hurricane Hugo slammed SC in 1989).
2) Tampa, Florida, observed two powerful hurricanes
in 1848, producing two of the three highest recorded water levels within the
same month. Surge levels reached 14 ft and 10 ft just a few weeks from each other. Since then, storm surge has not reached those levels, except for a
10.5 ft surge in 1921.
3) Between 1961 and 1980, South Texas experience
many intense hurricanes with massive storm surges. These storms included Carla
(1961), Beulah (1967), Celia (1970) and Allen (1980). The area has been
relatively quiet since 1980, the last year that Corpus Christi observed a storm
surge of at least 4 ft.
4) During the hurricane seasons of 2004-2005, seven hurricanes struck Florida. However, Hurricane Wilma (2005) was the last hurricane to strike the peninsula, as Florida has now experienced more than 10 years without a hurricane strike.
This topic of separating random variability from a long-term climate change trend warrants future research, as extreme weather events are costly and the science behind them is complex.
Hurricane Allen pounded the South Texas Coast with a massive storm surge and powerful waves in 1980. This flood event was part of a 20-year period of powerful storm surges in this region, but coastal floods in this area have had minor impacts since then. Image: http://maroonedinmarin.blogspot.com/2007/08/global-warming-being-blamed-for.html.
4) During the hurricane seasons of 2004-2005, seven hurricanes struck Florida. However, Hurricane Wilma (2005) was the last hurricane to strike the peninsula, as Florida has now experienced more than 10 years without a hurricane strike.
This topic of separating random variability from a long-term climate change trend warrants future research, as extreme weather events are costly and the science behind them is complex.
